Counterexample

First taught in High school geometry

Definition

A counterexample is any example proving that a statement is false. You only need one counterexample to prove that a statement is false.

Claim: √x < x for every xx = 0.25: √0.25 = 0.5 > 0.25✗ One counterexample shows it is false
One counterexample is enough to prove a statement false.
Advertisement

Using counterexamples

Is each statement true or false? If the statement is false, give a counterexample.

a.

The square root of a number is always smaller than the number.

The statement is false. The square root of 0.25 is a counterexample.

√(0.25) = 0.5 and 0.5 is not smaller than 0.25

b.

If a number is an irrational number, then squaring the number will also give an irrational number.

The statement is false. The √(3) is a counterexample.

√(3) = 1.73205080757 is irrational

However, [√(3)]2 = √(3) × √(3) = √(3×3) = √(9) = 3 and 3 is a rational number

c.

All birds can fly

The statement is false. Penguin is a counterexample.

d.

All integers are rational numbers

The statement is true

e.

No negative number is less than its absolute value.

The statement is false. -1 is a counterexample.

|-1| = 1 and -1 is less than 1

f.

If an animal lives on land, then it is a mammal.

The statement is false. A chicken is a counterexample.

A chicken lives on land, but it is a bird, not a mammal.

Advertisement